Cases in the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals: tenth-circuit.csv

This table contains the data behind the story For A Trump Nominee, Neil Gorsuch’s Record Is Surprisingly Moderate On Immigration

tenth-circuit.csv contains Tenth Circuit cases decided during Gorsuch’s tenure.

Field Description
Name Name of the case
Date Date of decision
Federal Reporter Citation Case citation, as listed in the Federal Reporter Series
Westlaw Citation Case citation, Westlaw format
Issue Issue number, in cases divided into multiple issues
Weight Weight per issue (total weight per case equals one)
Judge1 Name of first judge
Judge2 Name of second judge
Judge3 Name of third judge
Vote1 Vote of first judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Vote2 Vote of second judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Vote3 Vote of third judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Category Category of case, immigration or discrimination

Note: In immigration cases, partial relief to immigration petitioner is coded as liberal because the petitioner typically seeks just one core remedy (e.g., withholding of removal, adjustment of status, or asylum); in discrimination cases, partial relief is coded as multiple issues because the plaintiff often seeks separate remedies under multiple claims (e.g., disparate treatment, retaliation, etc.) and different sources of law.

Data license: CC Attribution 4.0 License · Data source: fivethirtyeight/data on GitHub

954 rows sorted by Weight

View and edit SQL

Suggested facets: Issue, Weight, Judge1, Judge2, Vote1, Vote2, Vote3, Category

Link rowid Title Date Federal Reporter Citation Westlaw Citation Issue Weight ▼ Judge1 Judge2 Judge3 Vote1 Vote2 Vote3 Category
1 Hansen v. SkyWest Airlines 12/21/16 844 F.3d 914 2016 WL 7387139 1 0.5 Briscoe McKay Matheson 1 1 1 Title VII
2 Hansen v. SkyWest Airlines 12/21/16 844 F.3d 914 2016 WL 7387139 2 0.5 Briscoe McKay Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
20 Unal v. Los Alamos Public Schools 01/29/16 638 Fed.Appx. 729 2016 WL 360758 1 0.5 Briscoe Lucero McHugh 1 1 1 Title VII
21 Unal v. Los Alamos Public Schools 01/29/16 638 Fed.Appx. 729 2016 WL 360758 2 0.5 Briscoe Lucero McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
28 Lounds v. Lincare, Inc. 12/22/15 812 F.3d 1208 2015 WL 9299074 1 0.5 Kelly Holmes McHugh 1 1 1 Title VII
29 Lounds v. Lincare, Inc. 12/22/15 812 F.3d 1208 2015 WL 9299074 2 0.5 Kelly Holmes McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
36 Zisumbo v. Ogden Regional Medical Center 09/04/15 801 F.3d 1185 2015 WL 5172860 1 0.5 Kelly Phillips Moritz 1 1 1 Title VII
37 Zisumbo v. Ogden Regional Medical Center 09/04/15 801 F.3d 1185 2015 WL 5172860 2 0.5 Kelly Phillips Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
38 Macias v. Southwest Cheese Co., LLC 08/24/15 624 Fed.Appx. 628 2015 WL 4998338 1 0.5 Holmes Matheson Bacharach 1 1 1 Title VII
39 Macias v. Southwest Cheese Co., LLC 08/24/15 624 Fed.Appx. 628 2015 WL 4998338 2 0.5 Holmes Matheson Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
45 Taite v. Ramos 07/08/15 618 Fed.Appx. 392 2015 WL 4098136 1 0.5 Hartz Phillips McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
46 Taite v. Ramos 07/08/15 618 Fed.Appx. 392 2015 WL 4098136 2 0.5 Hartz Phillips McHugh 1 1 1 Title VII
57 Riser v. QEP Energy 01/27/15 776 F.3d 1191 2015 WL 328597 1 0.5 Kelly Lucero Hartz 1 1 1 Title VII
58 Riser v. QEP Energy 01/27/15 776 F.3d 1191 2015 WL 328597 2 0.5 Kelly Lucero Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
71 Green v. Donahoe 07/28/14 760 F.3d 1135 2014 WL 3703823 1 0.5 Hartz McKay Matheson 1 1 1 Title VII
72 Green v. Donahoe 07/28/14 760 F.3d 1135 2014 WL 3703823 2 0.5 Hartz McKay Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
79 Ridgell-Boltz v. Colvin 04/30/14 565 Fed.Appx. 680 2014 WL 1688349 1 0.5 Gorsuch McKay Anderson 1 1 1 Title VII
80 Ridgell-Boltz v. Colvin 04/30/14 565 Fed.Appx. 680 2014 WL 1688349 2 0.5 Gorsuch McKay Anderson 0 0 0 Title VII
83 Potter v. Synerlink Corp. 04/21/14 562 Fed.Appx. 665 2014 WL 1562163 1 0.5 Lucero O'Brien Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
84 Potter v. Synerlink Corp. 04/21/14 562 Fed.Appx. 665 2014 WL 1562163 2 0.5 Lucero O'Brien Matheson 1 0 1 Title VII
86 Asebedo v. Kansas State University 03/17/14 559 Fed.Appx. 668 2014 WL 998417 1 0.5 Phillips McKay Anderson 1 1 1 Title VII
87 Asebedo v. Kansas State University 03/17/14 559 Fed.Appx. 668 2014 WL 998417 2 0.5 Phillips McKay Anderson 1 1 1 Title VII
88 Eisenhour v. Weber County 03/12/14 744 F.3d 1220 2014 WL 958468 1 0.5 Gorsuch Baldock Bacharach 1 1 1 Title VII
89 Eisenhour v. Weber County 03/12/14 744 F.3d 1220 2014 WL 958468 2 0.5 Gorsuch Baldock Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
90 Kramer v. Wasatch County Sheriff's Office 02/25/14 743 F.3d 726 121 Fair Empl.Prac.Cas. (BNA) 1329 1 0.5 Briscoe Seymour Bacharach 1 1 1 Title VII
91 Kramer v. Wasatch County Sheriff's Office 02/25/14 743 F.3d 726 121 Fair Empl.Prac.Cas. (BNA) 1329 2 0.5 Briscoe Seymour Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
108 E.E.O.C. v. Abercrombie & Fitch Stores, Inc. 10/01/13 731 F.3d 1106 2013 WL 5434809 1 0.5 Kelly Ebel Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
109 E.E.O.C. v. Abercrombie & Fitch Stores, Inc. 10/01/13 731 F.3d 1106 2013 WL 5434809 2 0.5 Kelly Ebel Holmes 0 1 0 Title VII
126 Tabor v. Hilti, Inc. 01/15/13 703 F.3d 1206 2013 WL 150225 1 0.5 Lucero O'Brien Matheson 1 1 1 Title VII
127 Tabor v. Hilti, Inc. 01/15/13 703 F.3d 1206 2013 WL 150225 2 0.5 Lucero O'Brien Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
128 Barlow v. C.R. England, Inc. 12/26/12 703 F.3d 497 2012 WL 6685467 1 0.5 Briscoe Gorsuch Matheson 1 1 1 Title VII
129 Barlow v. C.R. England, Inc. 12/26/12 703 F.3d 497 2012 WL 6685467 2 0.5 Briscoe Gorsuch Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
154 Bertsch v. Overstock.com 07/10/12 684 F.3d 1023 2012 WL 2756362 1 0.5 Kelly Murphy Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
155 Bertsch v. Overstock.com 07/10/12 684 F.3d 1023 2012 WL 2756362 2 0.5 Kelly Murphy Hartz 1 1 1 Title VII
156 Hernandez v. Valley View Hosp. Ass'n 06/26/12 684 F.3d 950 82 Fed.R.Serv.3d 1197 1 0.5 Kelly Murphy Matheson 1 1 1 Title VII
157 Hernandez v. Valley View Hosp. Ass'n 06/26/12 684 F.3d 950 82 Fed.R.Serv.3d 1197 2 0.5 Kelly Murphy Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
192 McInerney v. United Air Lines, Inc. 04/11/11 463 Fed.Appx. 709 2011 WL 1350453 1 0.5 Briscoe McKay Hartz 1 1 0 Title VII
193 McInerney v. United Air Lines, Inc. 04/11/11 463 Fed.Appx. 709 2011 WL 1350453 2 0.5 Briscoe McKay Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
194 Laughter v. Gallup Indian Medical Center 04/07/11 425 Fed.Appx. 683 2011 WL 1313711 1 0.5 Kelly Tacha Holloway 0 0 0 Title VII
195 Laughter v. Gallup Indian Medical Center 04/07/11 425 Fed.Appx. 683 2011 WL 1313711 2 0.5 Kelly Tacha Holloway 0 0 1 Title VII
206 Shaw v. Tulsa Dynaspan Arrow Concrete 01/28/11 408 Fed.Appx. 177 2011 WL 263205 1 0.5 Murphy McKay Holmes 1 1 1 Title VII
207 Shaw v. Tulsa Dynaspan Arrow Concrete 01/28/11 408 Fed.Appx. 177 2011 WL 263205 2 0.5 Murphy McKay Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
219 Flitton v. Primary Residential Mortg., Inc. 08/05/10 614 F.3d 1173 2010 WL 3035754 1 0.5 Tacha McKay Gorsuch 1 0 1 Title VII
220 Flitton v. Primary Residential Mortg., Inc. 08/05/10 614 F.3d 1173 2010 WL 3035754 2 0.5 Tacha McKay Gorsuch 0 0 1 Title VII
244 Schmidt v. Medicalodges, Inc. 10/20/09 350 Fed.Appx. 235 2009 WL 3358486 1 0.5 Tacha Seymour Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
245 Schmidt v. Medicalodges, Inc. 10/20/09 350 Fed.Appx. 235 2009 WL 3358486 2 0.5 Tacha Seymour Holmes 1 1 1 Title VII
251 DeFreitas v. Horizon Inv. Management Corp. 08/14/09 577 F.3d 1151 2009 WL 2482030 1 0.5 Hartz Holloway McKay 1 1 1 Title VII
252 DeFreitas v. Horizon Inv. Management Corp. 08/14/09 577 F.3d 1151 2009 WL 2482030 2 0.5 Hartz Holloway McKay 0 0 0 Title VII
254 Nettle v. Central Okla. American Indian Health Council, Inc. 07/01/09 334 Fed.Appx. 914 2009 WL 1877433 1 0.5 Kelly Briscoe McConnell 0 0 0 Title VII
255 Nettle v. Central Okla. American Indian Health Council, Inc. 07/01/09 334 Fed.Appx. 914 2009 WL 1877433 2 0.5 Kelly Briscoe McConnell 0 1 0 Title VII
267 Chapman v. Carmike Cinemas 01/12/09 307 Fed.Appx. 164 2009 WL 57504 1 0.5 Henry Ebel Gorsuch 1 1 1 Title VII
268 Chapman v. Carmike Cinemas 01/12/09 307 Fed.Appx. 164 2009 WL 57504 2 0.5 Henry Ebel Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
269 Semsroth v. City of Wichita 12/22/08 304 Fed.Appx. 707 2008 WL 5328466 1 0.5 Lucero Holloway Ebel 1 1 1 Title VII
270 Semsroth v. City of Wichita 12/22/08 304 Fed.Appx. 707 2008 WL 5328466 2 0.5 Lucero Holloway Ebel 0 0 0 Title VII
274 Sanders v. Southwestern Bell Telephone, L.P. 10/15/08 544 F.3d 1101 2008 WL 4570652 1 0.5 Tacha McKay Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
275 Sanders v. Southwestern Bell Telephone, L.P. 10/15/08 544 F.3d 1101 2008 WL 4570652 2 0.5 Tacha McKay Tymkovich 1 0 1 Title VII
289 Fischer v. Forestwood Co., Inc. 05/12/08 525 F.3d 972 2008 WL 2009866 1 0.5 Hartz McConnell Tymkovich 1 1 1 Title VII
290 Fischer v. Forestwood Co., Inc. 05/12/08 525 F.3d 972 2008 WL 2009866 2 0.5 Hartz McConnell Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
313 Keeler v. Cereal Food Processors 10/10/07 250 Fed.Appx. 857 2007 WL 2962384 1 0.5 Porfilio Anderson Baldock 1 1 1 Title VII
314 Keeler v. Cereal Food Processors 10/10/07 250 Fed.Appx. 857 2007 WL 2962384 2 0.5 Porfilio Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
322 Williams v. W.D. Sports, N.M., Inc. 08/07/07 497 F.3d 1079 2007 WL 2254940 1 0.5 Kelly Ebel Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
323 Williams v. W.D. Sports, N.M., Inc. 08/07/07 497 F.3d 1079 2007 WL 2254940 2 0.5 Kelly Ebel Gorsuch 1 1 1 Title VII
329 Santana v. City and County of Denver 05/24/07 488 F.3d 860 2007 WL 1502264 1 0.5 Briscoe McConnell Siler 1 1 1 Title VII
330 Santana v. City and County of Denver 05/24/07 488 F.3d 860 2007 WL 1502264 2 0.5 Briscoe McConnell Siler 0 0 0 Title VII
338 Piercy v. Maketa 03/27/07 480 F.3d 1192 2007 WL 901911 1 0.5 Briscoe Baldock Tymkovich 1 1 1 Title VII
339 Piercy v. Maketa 03/27/07 480 F.3d 1192 2007 WL 901911 2 0.5 Briscoe Baldock Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
349 Jenkins v. Educational Credit Management Corp. 01/04/07 212 Fed.Appx. 729 2007 WL 18919 1 0.5 Kelly Lucero Hartz 1 1 1 Title VII
350 Jenkins v. Educational Credit Management Corp. 01/04/07 212 Fed.Appx. 729 2007 WL 18919 2 0.5 Kelly Lucero Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
377 Zamora v. Elite Logistics, Inc. 06/05/06 449 F.3d 1106 2006 WL 1530103 1 0.5 Ebel Holloway Lucero 1 1 1 Title VII
378 Zamora v. Elite Logistics, Inc. 06/05/06 449 F.3d 1106 2006 WL 1530103 2 0.5 Ebel Holloway Lucero 1 0 0 Title VII
397 Maldonado v. City of Altus 01/11/06 433 F.3d 1294 2006 WL 52805 1 0.5 Seymour Hartz Brack 1 1 1 Title VII
398 Maldonado v. City of Altus 01/11/06 433 F.3d 1294 2006 WL 52805 2 0.5 Seymour Hartz Brack 1 0 0 Title VII
619 Sosa-Valenzuela v. Holder 08/31/12 692 F.3d 1103 2012 WL 3775976 1 0.5 Briscoe Tymkovich Eagan 1 1 1 Immigration
620 Sosa-Valenzuela v. Holder 08/31/12 692 F.3d 1103 2012 WL 3775976 2 0.5 Briscoe Tymkovich Eagan 0 0 0 Immigration
3 Glapion v. Jewell 12/14/16 --- Fed.Appx. ---- 2016 WL 7228801 1 1.0 Lucero Holmes Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
4 Dye v. Moniz 12/06/16 --- Fed.Appx. ---- 2016 WL 7093896 1 1.0 Lucero Holmes Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
5 Lister v. City of Wichita, Kansas 11/15/16 --- Fed.Appx. ---- 2016 WL 6694901 1 1.0 Lucero Matheson Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
6 ElHelbawy v. Pritzker 10/13/16 663 Fed.Appx. 658 2016 WL 5947456 1 1.0 Tymkovich Bacharach Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
7 Chung v. El Paso School District #11 08/11/16 659 Fed.Appx. 953 2016 WL 4258835 1 1.0 Hartz Holmes McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
8 Bird v. West Valley City 08/08/16 832 F.3d 1188 129 Fair Empl.Prac.Cas. (BNA) 685 1 1.0 Matheson Baldock Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
9 Drury v. BNSF Railway Company 08/02/16 657 Fed.Appx. 785 2016 WL 4119068 1 1.0 Tymkovich Lucero Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
10 Callahan v. Communication Graphics, Inc. 07/21/16 657 Fed.Appx. 739 2016 WL 3983511 1 1.0 Gorsuch Baldock McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
11 Williams v. McKee 07/20/16 655 Fed.Appx. 677 2016 WL 3995755 1 1.0 Tymkovich Murphy Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
12 Ghogomu v. Delta Airlines Global Services, LLC 06/16/16 652 Fed.Appx. 701 2016 WL 3409754 1 1.0 Briscoe Bacharach McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
13 Glapion v. Castro 05/12/16 646 Fed.Appx. 668 2016 WL 2755473 1 1.0 Kelly O'Brien Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
14 Johnson v. Oklahoma Department of Transp. 04/20/16 645 Fed.Appx. 765 2016 WL 1583596 1 1.0 Gorsuch McKay Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
15 Walton v. Powell 04/19/16 821 F.3d 1204 2016 WL 1566692 1 1.0 Gorsuch Murphy Moritz 1 1 1 Title VII
16 Aman v. Dillon Companies, Inc. 04/15/16 645 Fed.Appx. 719 2016 WL 1533999 1 1.0 Briscoe Lucero McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
17 McGowan v. Board of Trustees of Metropolitan State University of Denver 04/13/16 645 Fed.Appx. 667 2016 WL 1445420 1 1.0 Briscoe Lucero McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
18 Robinson v. St. John Medical Center, Inc. 04/13/16 645 Fed.Appx. 644 2016 WL 1444740 1 1.0 Gorsuch Matheson Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
19 Tuffa v. Flight Services & Systems, Inc. 04/05/16 644 Fed.Appx. 853 2016 WL 1319366 1 1.0 Gorsuch McKay Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
22 Hannah v. Cowlishaw 01/29/16 628 Fed.Appx. 629 2016 WL 362981 1 1.0 Lucero Gorsuch McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
23 Montoya v. Hunter Douglas Window Fashions, Inc. 01/25/16 636 Fed.Appx. 744 2016 WL 285057 1 1.0 Phillips McHugh Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
24 Mancell v. McHugh 01/25/16 639 Fed.Appx. 527 2016 WL 285087 1 1.0 Hartz Baldock Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
25 L'Ggrke v. Asset Plus Corp. 01/20/16 641 Fed.Appx. 779 2016 WL 231150 1 1.0 Hartz Baldock Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
26 Lewis v. Twenty-First Century Bean Processing 01/06/16 638 Fed.Appx. 701 2016 WL 66334 1 1.0 Gorsuch McKay Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
27 Amos v. City of Claremore 12/23/15 635 Fed.Appx. 517 2015 WL 9311375 1 1.0 Kelly Bacharach Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
30 Sanders v. Anoatubby 11/23/15 631 Fed.Appx. 618 2015 WL 7423038 1 1.0 Gorsuch O'Brien Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
31 McElroy v. American Family Ins. 10/30/15 630 Fed.Appx. 847 2015 WL 6576261 1 1.0 Briscoe Holmes Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
32 Hung Thai Pham v. James 10/20/15 630 Fed.Appx. 735 2015 WL 6144067 1 1.0 Tymkovich Holmes McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII

Next page

Advanced export

JSON shape: default, array, newline-delimited

CSV options:

CREATE TABLE "tenth-circuit/tenth-circuit" (
"Title" TEXT,
  "Date" TEXT,
  "Federal Reporter Citation" TEXT,
  "Westlaw Citation" TEXT,
  "Issue" INTEGER,
  "Weight" REAL,
  "Judge1" TEXT,
  "Judge2" TEXT,
  "Judge3" TEXT,
  "Vote1" INTEGER,
  "Vote2" INTEGER,
  "Vote3" INTEGER,
  "Category" TEXT
);
Powered by Datasette · Query took 145.265ms · Data license: CC Attribution 4.0 License · Data source: fivethirtyeight/data on GitHub