Cases in the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals: tenth-circuit.csv

This table contains the data behind the story For A Trump Nominee, Neil Gorsuch’s Record Is Surprisingly Moderate On Immigration

tenth-circuit.csv contains Tenth Circuit cases decided during Gorsuch’s tenure.

Field Description
Name Name of the case
Date Date of decision
Federal Reporter Citation Case citation, as listed in the Federal Reporter Series
Westlaw Citation Case citation, Westlaw format
Issue Issue number, in cases divided into multiple issues
Weight Weight per issue (total weight per case equals one)
Judge1 Name of first judge
Judge2 Name of second judge
Judge3 Name of third judge
Vote1 Vote of first judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Vote2 Vote of second judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Vote3 Vote of third judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Category Category of case, immigration or discrimination

Note: In immigration cases, partial relief to immigration petitioner is coded as liberal because the petitioner typically seeks just one core remedy (e.g., withholding of removal, adjustment of status, or asylum); in discrimination cases, partial relief is coded as multiple issues because the plaintiff often seeks separate remedies under multiple claims (e.g., disparate treatment, retaliation, etc.) and different sources of law.

Data license: CC Attribution 4.0 License · Data source: fivethirtyeight/data on GitHub

954 rows

View and edit SQL

Link rowid Title Date Federal Reporter Citation Westlaw Citation Issue Weight Judge1 Judge2 Judge3 Vote1 Vote2 Vote3 Category
101 Jeffrey v. CP Kelco U.S., Inc. 11/14/13 544 Fed.Appx. 817 2013 WL 6018615 1 1.0 Matheson Porfilio O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
102 Lobato v. New Mexico Environment Dept. 11/05/13 733 F.3d 1283 2013 WL 5912072 1 1.0 Tymkovich Seymour Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
103 Wright v. City of Topeka, Kan. 11/01/13 547 Fed.Appx. 861 2013 WL 5860724 1 1.0 Kelly Tymkovich Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
104 Bhomengo v. Hospital Shared Services, Inc. 10/29/13 543 Fed.Appx. 812 2013 WL 5789276 1 1.0 Kelly Holmes Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
105 Marquez v. Johnson 10/18/13 545 Fed.Appx. 735 2013 WL 5663834 1 1.0 Briscoe Anderson Brorby 0 0 0 Title VII
106 Ferguson v. Shinseki 10/17/13 543 Fed.Appx. 750 2013 WL 5651284 1 1.0 Hartz Baldock Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
107 Frederick v. Metropolitan State University of Denver Bd. of Trustees 10/03/13 535 Fed.Appx. 713 2013 WL 5482337 1 1.0 Hartz Baldock Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
108 E.E.O.C. v. Abercrombie & Fitch Stores, Inc. 10/01/13 731 F.3d 1106 2013 WL 5434809 1 0.5 Kelly Ebel Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
109 E.E.O.C. v. Abercrombie & Fitch Stores, Inc. 10/01/13 731 F.3d 1106 2013 WL 5434809 2 0.5 Kelly Ebel Holmes 0 1 0 Title VII
110 Salazar v. City of Commerce City 09/23/13 535 Fed.Appx. 692 2013 WL 5303257 1 1.0 Briscoe Anderson Brorby 0 0 0 Title VII
111 Leo v. Garmin Intern., Inc. 09/12/13 536 Fed.Appx. 813 2013 WL 4840497 1 1.0 Briscoe Anderson Brorby 0 0 0 Title VII
112 Keeler v. ARAMARK 08/21/13 536 Fed.Appx. 771 2013 WL 4437618 1 1.0 Hartz O'Brien Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
113 McCafferty v. Preiss Enterprises, Inc. 08/13/13 534 Fed.Appx. 726 2013 WL 4055480 1 1.0 Lucero Murphy Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
114 Borwick v. T-Mobile West Corp. 08/07/13 535 Fed.Appx. 650 2013 WL 4007740 1 1.0 Hartz Brorby Ebel 0 0 0 Title VII
115 Pettigrew v. Oklahoma ex rel. Oklahoma Dept. of Public Safety 07/15/13 722 F.3d 1209 2013 WL 3491643 1 1.0 Hartz McKay O'Brien 1 1 1 Title VII
116 Freppon v. City of Chandler 07/01/13 528 Fed.Appx. 892 2013 WL 3285628 1 1.0 Lucero Porfilio Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
117 Desai v. Panguitch Main Street, Inc. 06/05/13 527 Fed.Appx. 689 2013 WL 2435360 1 1.0 Lucero Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
118 Murdock v. City of Wichita, Kans. 05/23/13 525 Fed.Appx. 820 2013 WL 2249425 1 1.0 Lucero Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
119 Manning v. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City 04/12/13 522 Fed.Appx. 438 2013 WL 1490803 1 1.0 Briscoe Holloway Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
120 Rochelle v. Hy-Vee, Inc. 03/22/13 514 Fed.Appx. 706 2013 WL 1171382 1 1.0 O'Brien McKay Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
121 Luke v. Hospital Shared Services, Inc. 03/20/13 513 Fed.Appx. 763 2013 WL 1136937 1 1.0 Kelly McKay O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
122 Paige v. Donovan 02/19/13 511 Fed.Appx. 729 2013 WL 599796 1 1.0 Hartz Anderson Ebel 0 0 0 Title VII
123 Conroy v. Vilsack 02/11/13 707 F.3d 1163 2013 WL 491546 1 1.0 Tymkovich Ebel Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
124 Espinoza v. Department of Corrections 02/04/13 509 Fed.Appx. 724 2013 WL 409676 1 1.0 Briscoe Gorsuch Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
125 Robles v. Amarr Garage Doors 02/04/13 509 Fed.Appx. 741 2013 WL 409913 1 1.0 Lucero O'Brien Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
126 Tabor v. Hilti, Inc. 01/15/13 703 F.3d 1206 2013 WL 150225 1 0.5 Lucero O'Brien Matheson 1 1 1 Title VII
127 Tabor v. Hilti, Inc. 01/15/13 703 F.3d 1206 2013 WL 150225 2 0.5 Lucero O'Brien Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
128 Barlow v. C.R. England, Inc. 12/26/12 703 F.3d 497 2012 WL 6685467 1 0.5 Briscoe Gorsuch Matheson 1 1 1 Title VII
129 Barlow v. C.R. England, Inc. 12/26/12 703 F.3d 497 2012 WL 6685467 2 0.5 Briscoe Gorsuch Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
130 Gaff v. St. Mary's Regional Medical Center 12/19/12 506 Fed.Appx. 726 2012 WL 6604579 1 1.0 Gorsuch Anderson Ebel 0 0 0 Title VII
131 Kinney v. Blue Dot Services of Kansas 12/18/12 505 Fed.Appx. 812 2012 WL 6582375 1 1.0 Kelly Tymkovich Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
132 Daniels v. United Parcel Service, Inc. 12/11/12 701 F.3d 620 2012 WL 6131853 1 1.0 Tymkovich Baldock Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
133 Held v. Ferrellgas, Inc. 12/07/12 505 Fed.Appx. 687 2012 WL 6062662 1 1.0 Lucero Hartz O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
134 Kaiser v. Colorado Dept. of Corrections 12/05/12 504 Fed.Appx. 739 2012 WL 6032265 1 1.0 Gorsuch Anderson Ebel 0 0 0 Title VII
135 Weeks v. Kansas 11/29/12 503 Fed.Appx. 640 2012 WL 5951609 1 1.0 Tymkovich Baldock Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
136 Nichols v. Kansas Dept. of Corrections 11/27/12 503 Fed.Appx. 573 2012 WL 5908906 1 1.0 Murphy Ebel Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
137 Brown v. ScriptPro, LLC 11/27/12 700 F.3d 1222 19 Wage & Hour Cas.2d (BNA) 1675 1 1.0 Kelly Holloway Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
138 Xia v. Salazar 11/27/12 503 Fed.Appx. 577 2012 WL 5909096 1 1.0 Kelly O'Brien Matheson 1 1 1 Title VII
139 Green v. JP Morgan Chase Bank Nat. Ass'n 11/01/12 501 Fed.Appx. 727 2012 WL 5359294 1 1.0 Gorsuch Anderson Ebel 0 0 0 Title VII
140 Mobley v. Donahoe 10/05/12 498 Fed.Appx. 793 2012 WL 4748162 1 1.0 Hartz Anderson Ebel 0 0 0 Title VII
141 Shah v. Oklahoma, ex rel. Oklahoma Dept. of Mental Health and Substance Abuse 09/11/12 485 Fed.Appx. 971 2012 WL 3935699 1 1.0 Tymkovich Holloway Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
142 Lucero v. Sandia Corp. 08/28/12 495 Fed.Appx. 903 2012 WL 3667449 1 1.0 Holmes Ebel Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
143 Apsley v. Boeing Co. 08/27/12 691 F.3d 1184 2012 WL 3642800 1 1.0 Briscoe Baldock Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
144 Smith v. Wynne 08/20/12 494 Fed.Appx. 867 2012 WL 3553722 1 1.0 Briscoe McKay Lucero 0 0 0 Title VII
145 Getachew v. Google, Inc. 08/09/12 491 Fed.Appx. 923 2012 WL 3217611 1 1.0 Lucero O'Brien Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
146 Keller v. Crown Cork & Seal USA, Inc. 08/08/12 491 Fed.Appx. 908 2012 WL 3196002 1 1.0 Hartz Anderson O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
147 McBride v. Peak Wellness Center, Inc. 08/06/12 688 F.3d 698 2012 WL 3156325 1 1.0 Kelly Baldock Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
148 Konzak v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. 08/01/12 492 Fed.Appx. 906 2012 WL 3104872 1 1.0 Briscoe McKay Lucero 0 0 0 Title VII
149 Eke v. CaridianBCT, Inc. 07/31/12 490 Fed.Appx. 156 2012 WL 3089714 1 1.0 Hartz Anderson O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
150 Brown v. YRC, Inc. 07/30/12 490 Fed.Appx. 952 2012 WL 3064831 1 1.0 Briscoe Porfilio Murphy 1 1 1 Title VII
151 Somerlott v. Cherokee Nation Distributors, Inc. 07/27/12 686 F.3d 1144 2012 WL 3055566 1 1.0 Murphy Brorby Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
152 Kennington v. U.S. Dept. of the Treasury 07/26/12 490 Fed.Appx. 939 2012 WL 3038156 1 1.0 Kelly Hartz Holmes 1 1 1 Title VII
153 Tran v. Sonic Industries Services, Inc. 07/19/12 490 Fed.Appx. 115 2012 WL 2928521 1 1.0 Lucero McKay Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
154 Bertsch v. Overstock.com 07/10/12 684 F.3d 1023 2012 WL 2756362 1 0.5 Kelly Murphy Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
155 Bertsch v. Overstock.com 07/10/12 684 F.3d 1023 2012 WL 2756362 2 0.5 Kelly Murphy Hartz 1 1 1 Title VII
156 Hernandez v. Valley View Hosp. Ass'n 06/26/12 684 F.3d 950 82 Fed.R.Serv.3d 1197 1 0.5 Kelly Murphy Matheson 1 1 1 Title VII
157 Hernandez v. Valley View Hosp. Ass'n 06/26/12 684 F.3d 950 82 Fed.R.Serv.3d 1197 2 0.5 Kelly Murphy Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
158 Baltazar v. Shinseki 06/25/12 485 Fed.Appx. 941 2012 WL 2369332 1 1.0 Murphy Gorsuch Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
159 Ford v. Donley 06/18/12 485 Fed.Appx. 305 2012 WL 2236695 1 1.0 Briscoe Porfilio Murphy 0 0 0 Title VII
160 Larson v. United Air Lines 06/01/12 482 Fed.Appx. 344 2012 WL 1959471 1 1.0 Murphy Hartz Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
161 Morris v. Cabela's Wholesale, Inc. 05/29/12 486 Fed.Appx. 701 2012 WL 1925542 1 1.0 Lucero McKay Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
162 Hearron v. Voith Indus. Services, Inc. 05/24/12 483 Fed.Appx. 453 2012 WL 1881721 1 1.0 Briscoe Porfilio Murphy 0 0 0 Title VII
163 Battle v. J-M Mfg. Co., Inc. 05/24/12 483 Fed.Appx. 455 2012 WL 1881727 1 1.0 Tymkovich Baldock Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
164 Kenney v. AG Equipment Co. 02/21/12 462 Fed.Appx. 841 2012 WL 540783 1 1.0 Briscoe McKay Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
165 Park v. TD Ameritrade Trust Co., Inc. 02/14/12 461 Fed.Appx. 753 2012 WL 453630 1 1.0 Kelly Murphy Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
166 Johnson v. Sedgwick County Sheriff's Dept. 02/14/12 461 Fed.Appx. 756 2012 WL 453637 1 1.0 Hartz Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
167 Boese v. Fort Hays State University 02/09/12 462 Fed.Appx. 797 2012 WL 401519 1 1.0 Hartz Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
168 Khalik v. United Air Lines 02/06/12 671 F.3d 1188 2012 WL 364058 1 1.0 Briscoe McKay O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
169 Sampson v. Integra Telecom Holdings, Inc. 02/06/12 461 Fed.Appx. 670 2012 WL 361999 1 1.0 Tymkovich Seymour Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
170 Brown v. Unified School Dist. No. 501 02/01/12 459 Fed.Appx. 705 2012 WL 287500 1 1.0 Kelly Murphy Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
171 Igwe v. Saint Anthony's Hosp. 01/31/12 464 Fed.Appx. 685 2012 WL 266955 1 1.0 Briscoe Murphy Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
172 Yarberry v. Vilsack 01/31/12 460 Fed.Appx. 736 2012 WL 266931 1 1.0 Tymkovich Brorby Ebel 0 0 0 Title VII
173 Patillo v. Larned State Hosp. 01/30/12 462 Fed.Appx. 780 2012 WL 256023 1 1.0 Hartz Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
174 Morris v. City of Colorado Springs 01/18/12 666 F.3d 654 2012 WL 130672 1 1.0 O'Brien Gilman Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
175 Field v. Board of Water Com'rs, City and County of Denver 12/30/11 453 Fed.Appx. 811 2011 WL 6881794 1 1.0 Kelly Porfilio Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
176 Hoko v. Huish Detergents, Inc. 12/27/11 453 Fed.Appx. 799 2011 WL 6762962 1 1.0 Hartz Holloway Porfilio 0 0 0 Title VII
177 Carrera v. Tyson Foods, Inc. 12/01/11 449 Fed.Appx. 753 2011 WL 6000551 1 1.0 Lucero Anderson Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
178 Luster v. Vilsack 12/01/11 667 F.3d 1089 2011 WL 6000545 1 1.0 Murphy Anderson Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
179 Gross v. General Motors LLC 10/06/11 441 Fed.Appx. 562 2011 WL 4599683 1 1.0 Murphy Porfilio Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
180 Helm v. Kansas 09/07/11 656 F.3d 1277 2011 WL 3907126 1 1.0 Kelly Ebel Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
181 Norouzian v. University of Kansas Hosp. Authority 08/31/11 438 Fed.Appx. 677 2011 WL 3856984 1 1.0 Kelly Gorsuch Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
182 Bagwell v. Safeway Denver Milk Plant 08/25/11 437 Fed.Appx. 689 2011 WL 3733863 1 1.0 Briscoe Murphy Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
183 Honeyfield v. City of Gallup 08/02/11 436 Fed.Appx. 836 2011 WL 3288374 1 1.0 Briscoe Holloway O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
184 White v. Schafer 07/28/11 435 Fed.Appx. 764 2011 WL 3201632 1 1.0 O'Brien Anderson Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
185 Leo v. Garmin Intern., Inc. 07/21/11 431 Fed.Appx. 702 2011 WL 2908949 1 1.0 Tymkovich Baldock Brorby 0 0 0 Title VII
186 Parker v. Salazar 07/18/11 431 Fed.Appx. 697 2011 WL 2783995 1 1.0 Briscoe Ebel O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
187 Christian v. AHS Tulsa Regional Medical Center, LLC 07/15/11 430 Fed.Appx. 694 2011 WL 2745798 1 1.0 Tymkovich Porfilio Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
188 Powell v. Laborers Union No. 1271 06/07/11 426 Fed.Appx. 615 2011 WL 2197647 1 1.0 Matheson McKay Ebel 0 0 0 Title VII
189 Aduddell v. Gardner Tanenbaum Group, L.L.C. 06/06/11 425 Fed.Appx. 698 2011 WL 2176181 1 1.0 Lucero McKay Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
190 McDonald-Cuba v. Santa Fe Protective Services, Inc. 05/09/11 644 F.3d 1096 2011 WL 1746204 1 1.0 O'Brien Anderson Tacha 0 0 0 Title VII
191 Crowe v. ADT Sec. Services, Inc. 04/25/11 649 F.3d 1189 2011 WL 1532536 1 1.0 Kelly Seymour Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
192 McInerney v. United Air Lines, Inc. 04/11/11 463 Fed.Appx. 709 2011 WL 1350453 1 0.5 Briscoe McKay Hartz 1 1 0 Title VII
193 McInerney v. United Air Lines, Inc. 04/11/11 463 Fed.Appx. 709 2011 WL 1350453 2 0.5 Briscoe McKay Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
194 Laughter v. Gallup Indian Medical Center 04/07/11 425 Fed.Appx. 683 2011 WL 1313711 1 0.5 Kelly Tacha Holloway 0 0 0 Title VII
195 Laughter v. Gallup Indian Medical Center 04/07/11 425 Fed.Appx. 683 2011 WL 1313711 2 0.5 Kelly Tacha Holloway 0 0 1 Title VII
196 Kline v. Utah Anti-Discrimination and Labor Div. 04/07/11 418 Fed.Appx. 774 2011 WL 1313781 1 1.0 Briscoe McKay Kelly 0 0 0 Title VII
197 Calloway v. Aerojet General Corp. 04/05/11 419 Fed.Appx. 840 2011 WL 1241914 1 1.0 Lucero Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
198 Wheeler v. BNSF Ry. Co. 04/04/11 418 Fed.Appx. 738 2011 WL 1226935 1 1.0 Briscoe Ebel Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
199 Higgins v. Potter 03/22/11 416 Fed.Appx. 731 2011 WL 984313 1 1.0 Holmes McKay Porfilio 0 0 0 Title VII
200 Pretlow v. Garrison 03/22/11 420 Fed.Appx. 798 2011 WL 989849 1 1.0 Lucero Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII

Next page

Advanced export

JSON shape: default, array, newline-delimited

CSV options:

CREATE TABLE "tenth-circuit/tenth-circuit" (
"Title" TEXT,
  "Date" TEXT,
  "Federal Reporter Citation" TEXT,
  "Westlaw Citation" TEXT,
  "Issue" INTEGER,
  "Weight" REAL,
  "Judge1" TEXT,
  "Judge2" TEXT,
  "Judge3" TEXT,
  "Vote1" INTEGER,
  "Vote2" INTEGER,
  "Vote3" INTEGER,
  "Category" TEXT
)
Powered by Datasette · Query took 1718.499ms · Data license: CC Attribution 4.0 License · Data source: fivethirtyeight/data on GitHub