Cases in the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals: tenth-circuit.csv

This table contains the data behind the story For A Trump Nominee, Neil Gorsuch’s Record Is Surprisingly Moderate On Immigration

tenth-circuit.csv contains Tenth Circuit cases decided during Gorsuch’s tenure.

Field Description
Name Name of the case
Date Date of decision
Federal Reporter Citation Case citation, as listed in the Federal Reporter Series
Westlaw Citation Case citation, Westlaw format
Issue Issue number, in cases divided into multiple issues
Weight Weight per issue (total weight per case equals one)
Judge1 Name of first judge
Judge2 Name of second judge
Judge3 Name of third judge
Vote1 Vote of first judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Vote2 Vote of second judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Vote3 Vote of third judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Category Category of case, immigration or discrimination

Note: In immigration cases, partial relief to immigration petitioner is coded as liberal because the petitioner typically seeks just one core remedy (e.g., withholding of removal, adjustment of status, or asylum); in discrimination cases, partial relief is coded as multiple issues because the plaintiff often seeks separate remedies under multiple claims (e.g., disparate treatment, retaliation, etc.) and different sources of law.

Data license: CC Attribution 4.0 License · Data source: fivethirtyeight/data on GitHub

954 rows sorted by Date

View and edit SQL

Suggested facets: Issue, Weight, Judge1, Judge2, Vote1, Vote2, Vote3, Category

Link rowid Title Date ▼ Federal Reporter Citation Westlaw Citation Issue Weight Judge1 Judge2 Judge3 Vote1 Vote2 Vote3 Category
349 Jenkins v. Educational Credit Management Corp. 01/04/07 212 Fed.Appx. 729 2007 WL 18919 1 0.5 Kelly Lucero Hartz 1 1 1 Title VII
350 Jenkins v. Educational Credit Management Corp. 01/04/07 212 Fed.Appx. 729 2007 WL 18919 2 0.5 Kelly Lucero Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
351 Herrera v. Lufkin Industries, Inc. 01/04/07 474 F.3d 675 2007 WL 63663 1 1.0 Tacha Ebel Cassell 1 1 0 Title VII
209 Bronakowski v. Boulder Valley School Dist. 01/04/11 406 Fed.Appx. 304 2011 WL 9801 1 1.0 Briscoe Tacha O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
240 Stanley v. Abacus Technology Corp. 01/05/10 359 Fed.Appx. 926 2010 WL 11064 1 1.0 O'Brien Porfilio Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
689 Maingi v. Holder 01/05/11 406 Fed.Appx. 324 2011 WL 14470 1 1.0 Hartz Brorby Tymkovich 0 0 0 Immigration
400 Essary v. Federal Express Corp. 01/06/06 161 Fed.Appx. 782 2006 WL 31128 1 1.0 Lucero Brorby McConnell 0 0 0 Title VII
644 Zhi Wei Pang v. Holder 01/06/12 665 F.3d 1226 2012 WL 28950 1 1.0 Kelly Siler Matheson 0 0 0 Immigration
26 Lewis v. Twenty-First Century Bean Processing 01/06/16 638 Fed.Appx. 701 2016 WL 66334 1 1.0 Gorsuch McKay Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
98 Buhendwa v. Regional Transp. Dist. 01/07/14 553 Fed.Appx. 768 2014 WL 44001 1 1.0 Lucero Brorby Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
591 Cifuentes v. Holder 01/08/13 506 Fed.Appx. 851 2013 WL 71524 1 1.0 Kelly McKay O'Brien 0 0 0 Immigration
954 Wei v. Gonzales 01/09/06 161 Fed.Appx. 795 2006 WL 41225 1 1.0 Briscoe McConnell Tymkovich 0 0 0 Immigration
308 Naifeh v. Ideal Homes of Norman, L.P. 01/09/08 260 Fed.Appx. 122 2008 WL 102418 1 1.0 Kelly McKay Anderson 0 0 0 Title VII
309 Dean v. Boeing Co. 01/09/08 260 Fed.Appx. 124 2008 WL 102420 1 1.0 Kelly Porfilio Anderson 0 0 0 Title VII
643 Abajue v. Holder 01/09/12 453 Fed.Appx. 853 2012 WL 34505 1 1.0 Hartz Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Immigration
97 Benton v. Town of South Fork and Police Dept. 01/09/14 553 Fed.Appx. 772 2014 WL 67867 1 1.0 Lucero Brorby Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
399 Mitchell v. Kraft Pizza Co. 01/10/06 162 Fed.Appx. 801 2006 WL 52787 1 1.0 Kelly McKay McConnell 0 0 0 Title VII
348 Crumpacker v. Kansas, Dept. of Human Resources 01/10/07 474 F.3d 747 2007 WL 60878 1 1.0 Lucero Anderson Tymkovich 1 1 1 Title VII
843 Turangan v. Mukasey 01/10/08 260 Fed.Appx. 132 2008 WL 110993 1 1.0 Kelly Porfilio Anderson 0 0 0 Immigration
642 Hansraj v. Holder 01/10/12 456 Fed.Appx. 743 2012 WL 57242 1 1.0 Kelly Gorsuch Matheson 0 0 0 Immigration
590 Na Zheng v. Holder 01/10/13 507 Fed.Appx. 755 2013 WL 116811 1 1.0 Kelly O'Brien Matheson 1 1 1 Immigration
397 Maldonado v. City of Altus 01/11/06 433 F.3d 1294 2006 WL 52805 1 0.5 Seymour Hartz Brack 1 1 1 Title VII
398 Maldonado v. City of Altus 01/11/06 433 F.3d 1294 2006 WL 52805 2 0.5 Seymour Hartz Brack 1 0 0 Title VII
307 Dehning v. Child Development Services of Fremont County 01/11/08 261 Fed.Appx. 75 2008 WL 123533 1 1.0 Tacha McConnell Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
641 Rivera-Barrientos v. Holder 01/11/12 666 F.3d 641 2012 WL 75974 1 1.0 Tymkovich Brorby Matheson 0 0 0 Immigration
589 Zuniga-Espinoza v. Holder 01/11/13 507 Fed.Appx. 778 2013 WL 136016 1 1.0 Hartz Ebel Gorsuch 0 0 0 Immigration
899 Kalule v. Gonzales 01/12/07 213 Fed.Appx. 657 2007 WL 80700 1 1.0 Porfilio Baldock Ebel 0 0 0 Immigration
267 Chapman v. Carmike Cinemas 01/12/09 307 Fed.Appx. 164 2009 WL 57504 1 0.5 Henry Ebel Gorsuch 1 1 1 Title VII
268 Chapman v. Carmike Cinemas 01/12/09 307 Fed.Appx. 164 2009 WL 57504 2 0.5 Henry Ebel Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
738 Carpio v. Holder 01/12/10 592 F.3d 1091 2010 WL 93107 1 1.0 Henry Murphy Tymkovich 1 1 1 Immigration
208 Faragalla v. Douglas County School Dist. RE 1 01/12/11 411 Fed.Appx. 140 2011 WL 94540 1 1.0 Briscoe Tymkovich Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
688 Krylov v. Holder 01/12/11 407 Fed.Appx. 290 2011 WL 94548 1 1.0 Tacha Anderson Kelly 1 1 1 Immigration
429 Daoi Kai He v. Lynch 01/12/16 638 Fed.Appx. 717 2016 WL 124450 1 1.0 Tymkovich Hartz Moritz 0 0 0 Immigration
396 Lombardo v. Potter 01/13/06 166 Fed.Appx. 319 2006 WL 75364 1 1.0 Kelly Porfilio Brorby 0 0 0 Title VII
787 Rahadi v. Mukasey 01/13/09 307 Fed.Appx. 197 2009 WL 74472 1 1.0 Murphy McKay Anderson 0 0 0 Immigration
788 Xing Lin v. Chertoff 01/13/09 307 Fed.Appx. 175 2009 WL 74405 1 1.0 Kelly Porfilio O'Brien 0 0 0 Immigration
60 Brainard v. City of Topeka 01/13/15 597 Fed.Appx. 974 2015 WL 150288 1 1.0 Kelly Anderson Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
266 Sunderman v. Westar Energy, Inc. 01/14/09 307 Fed.Appx. 224 2009 WL 81009 1 1.0 O'Brien McConnell Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
306 Haynes v. Kansas 01/15/08 261 Fed.Appx. 87 2008 WL 142783 1 1.0 Holmes Holloway Seymour 0 0 0 Title VII
126 Tabor v. Hilti, Inc. 01/15/13 703 F.3d 1206 2013 WL 150225 1 0.5 Lucero O'Brien Matheson 1 1 1 Title VII
127 Tabor v. Hilti, Inc. 01/15/13 703 F.3d 1206 2013 WL 150225 2 0.5 Lucero O'Brien Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
59 Davis v. James 01/15/15 597 Fed.Appx. 983 2015 WL 178982 1 1.0 Kelly Anderson Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
842 Kabing v. Mukasey 01/17/08 261 Fed.Appx. 120 2008 WL 154441 1 1.0 Tacha Ebel Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
953 Infanzon v. Comfort 01/18/06 167 Fed.Appx. 11 2006 WL 122450 1 1.0 Briscoe Lucero Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
305 Somoza v. University of Denver 01/18/08 513 F.3d 1206 2008 WL 162764 1 1.0 Lucero Holloway Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
841 Turgerel v. Mukasey 01/18/08 513 F.3d 1202 2008 WL 161675 1 1.0 Kelly McKay Anderson 0 0 0 Immigration
174 Morris v. City of Colorado Springs 01/18/12 666 F.3d 654 2012 WL 130672 1 1.0 O'Brien Gilman Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
394 Douglas v. Norton 01/19/06 167 Fed.Appx. 698 2006 WL 137403 1 1.0 Kelly Anderson O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
395 Curran v. AMI Fireplace Co. Inc. 01/19/06 163 Fed.Appx. 714 2006 WL 137405 1 1.0 Briscoe McKay Ebel 1 1 1 Title VII
25 L'Ggrke v. Asset Plus Corp. 01/20/16 641 Fed.Appx. 779 2016 WL 231150 1 1.0 Hartz Baldock Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
96 Hester v. Jewell 01/21/14 553 Fed.Appx. 783 2014 WL 211868 1 1.0 Lucero McKay Murphy 0 0 0 Title VII
428 Gutierrez-Orozco v. Lynch 01/21/16 810 F.3d 1243 2016 WL 240595 1 1.0 Bacharach O'Brien Phillips 0 0 0 Immigration
898 Sarr v. Gonzales 01/22/07 474 F.3d 783 2007 WL 140953 1 1.0 Lucero McConnell Holmes 1 1 1 Immigration
588 Mukhia v. Holder 01/22/13 507 Fed.Appx. 824 2013 WL 226884 1 1.0 Kelly McKay O'Brien 1 1 1 Immigration
347 Cooper v. American Airlines, Inc. 01/23/07 213 Fed.Appx. 714 2007 WL 155841 1 1.0 Holmes McKay Brorby 0 0 0 Title VII
897 Mucuuthi v. Gonzales 01/23/07 213 Fed.Appx. 717 2007 WL 156024 1 1.0 Kelly Lucero Hartz 0 0 0 Immigration
840 Mei Eng Joe v. Mukasey 01/23/08 262 Fed.Appx. 96 2008 WL 193238 1 1.0 Tacha Ebel Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
786 Johan v. Filip 01/23/09 309 Fed.Appx. 227 2009 WL 159579 1 1.0 Murphy McKay Anderson 0 0 0 Immigration
488 Mena-Flores v. Holder 01/23/15 776 F.3d 1152 2015 WL 294629 1 1.0 Holmes Bacharach McHugh 0 0 0 Immigration
951 Infanzon v. Gonzales 01/24/06 164 Fed.Appx. 743 2006 WL 165039 1 1.0 Henry McKay Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
952 Otero v. Gonzales 01/24/06 164 Fed.Appx. 732 2006 WL 165012 1 1.0 Tymkovich Porfilio Baldock 0 0 0 Immigration
95 Zamora v. Board of Educ. for Las Cruces Public Schools 01/24/14 553 Fed.Appx. 786 2014 WL 260293 1 1.0 Lucero Baldock Brorby 0 0 0 Title VII
543 Sharma v. Holder 01/24/14 552 Fed.Appx. 835 2014 WL 260551 1 1.0 Hartz McKay Bacharach 0 0 0 Immigration
346 Hardman v. AutoZone, Inc. 01/25/07 214 Fed.Appx. 758 2007 WL 182535 1 1.0 Tymkovich Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
239 Fisher v. Southwestern Bell Telephone Co. 01/25/10 361 Fed.Appx. 974 2010 WL 257305 1 1.0 Murphy McKay Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
640 Martinez-Diaz v. Holder 01/25/12 457 Fed.Appx. 774 2012 WL 207062 1 1.0 Hartz Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Immigration
23 Montoya v. Hunter Douglas Window Fashions, Inc. 01/25/16 636 Fed.Appx. 744 2016 WL 285057 1 1.0 Phillips McHugh Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
24 Mancell v. McHugh 01/25/16 639 Fed.Appx. 527 2016 WL 285087 1 1.0 Hartz Baldock Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
896 Abiodun v. Gonzales 01/26/07 217 Fed.Appx. 738 2007 WL 196572 1 1.0 Holmes McKay Brorby 0 0 0 Immigration
737 Tju v. Holder 01/26/10 Slip Copy 2010 WL 286611 1 1.0 Kelly Porfilio O'Brien 0 0 0 Immigration
687 Olivan-Duenas v. Holder 01/26/11 416 Fed.Appx. 678 2011 WL 223804 1 1.0 Kelly Baldock Brorby 0 0 0 Immigration
427 Guru v. Lynch 01/26/16 637 Fed.Appx. 501 2016 WL 308572 1 1.0 Kelly Lucero McHugh 0 0 0 Immigration
238 Anderson v. AOL, LLC 01/27/10 363 Fed.Appx. 581 2010 WL 299256 1 1.0 Henry Briscoe Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
57 Riser v. QEP Energy 01/27/15 776 F.3d 1191 2015 WL 328597 1 0.5 Kelly Lucero Hartz 1 1 1 Title VII
58 Riser v. QEP Energy 01/27/15 776 F.3d 1191 2015 WL 328597 2 0.5 Kelly Lucero Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
785 Oseiwusu v. Filip 01/28/09 309 Fed.Appx. 253 2009 WL 190085 1 1.0 Kelly Porfilio O'Brien 0 0 0 Immigration
206 Shaw v. Tulsa Dynaspan Arrow Concrete 01/28/11 408 Fed.Appx. 177 2011 WL 263205 1 0.5 Murphy McKay Holmes 1 1 1 Title VII
207 Shaw v. Tulsa Dynaspan Arrow Concrete 01/28/11 408 Fed.Appx. 177 2011 WL 263205 2 0.5 Murphy McKay Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
686 Ritonga v. Holder 01/28/11 633 F.3d 971 2011 WL 258380 1 1.0 Tymkovich Seymour Baldock 0 0 0 Immigration
94 White v. Oklahoma 01/28/14 552 Fed.Appx. 840 2014 WL 292448 1 1.0 Tymkovich Anderson Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
487 Juarez-Gonzalez v. Holder 01/28/15 597 Fed.Appx. 524 2015 WL 347478 1 1.0 Kelly Baldock Moritz 0 0 0 Immigration
895 Serva-Lozano v. Gonzales 01/29/07 215 Fed.Appx. 704 2007 WL 211282 1 1.0 Kelly McKay Lucero 0 0 0 Immigration
93 Richardson v. Gallagher 01/29/14 553 Fed.Appx. 816 122 Fair Empl.Prac.Cas. (BNA) 12 1 1.0 Tymkovich Brorby Murphy 0 0 0 Title VII
20 Unal v. Los Alamos Public Schools 01/29/16 638 Fed.Appx. 729 2016 WL 360758 1 0.5 Briscoe Lucero McHugh 1 1 1 Title VII
21 Unal v. Los Alamos Public Schools 01/29/16 638 Fed.Appx. 729 2016 WL 360758 2 0.5 Briscoe Lucero McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
22 Hannah v. Cowlishaw 01/29/16 628 Fed.Appx. 629 2016 WL 362981 1 1.0 Lucero Gorsuch McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
426 Zhang v. Lynch 01/29/16 633 Fed.Appx. 701 2016 WL 362505 1 1.0 Hartz Baldock Holmes 0 0 0 Immigration
173 Patillo v. Larned State Hosp. 01/30/12 462 Fed.Appx. 780 2012 WL 256023 1 1.0 Hartz Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
950 Haimour v. Gonzales 01/31/06 165 Fed.Appx. 594 2006 WL 226042 1 1.0 Henry McKay Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
345 Harsco Corp. v. Renner 01/31/07 475 F.3d 1179 2007 WL 259684 1 1.0 Briscoe Holloway McConnell 1 1 1 Title VII
205 Nanomantube v. Kickapoo Tribe in Kansas 01/31/11 631 F.3d 1150 2011 WL 285520 1 1.0 Tymkovich McKay Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
171 Igwe v. Saint Anthony's Hosp. 01/31/12 464 Fed.Appx. 685 2012 WL 266955 1 1.0 Briscoe Murphy Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
172 Yarberry v. Vilsack 01/31/12 460 Fed.Appx. 736 2012 WL 266931 1 1.0 Tymkovich Brorby Ebel 0 0 0 Title VII
542 Lin Yan v. Holder 01/31/14 559 Fed.Appx. 658 2014 WL 341442 1 1.0 Gorsuch Anderson Holmes 0 0 0 Immigration
304 Adamson v. Multi Community Diversified Services, Inc. 02/01/08 514 F.3d 1136 2008 WL 274736 1 1.0 Tacha Ebel Kane 0 0 0 Title VII
839 Markosyan v. Mukasey 02/01/08 262 Fed.Appx. 918 2008 WL 276060 1 1.0 Tacha Ebel Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
204 Muller v. Culbertson 02/01/11 408 Fed.Appx. 194 2011 WL 304484 1 1.0 Kelly Baldock Brorby 0 0 0 Title VII
685 Bhattarai v. Holder 02/01/11 408 Fed.Appx. 212 2011 WL 304789 1 1.0 Lucero Gorsuch Arguello 1 0 0 Immigration
170 Brown v. Unified School Dist. No. 501 02/01/12 459 Fed.Appx. 705 2012 WL 287500 1 1.0 Kelly Murphy Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
425 Condor-Araujo v. Lynch 02/01/16 636 Fed.Appx. 759 2016 WL 373724 1 1.0 Hartz Baldock Moritz 0 0 0 Immigration

Next page

Advanced export

JSON shape: default, array, newline-delimited

CSV options:

CREATE TABLE "tenth-circuit/tenth-circuit" (
"Title" TEXT,
  "Date" TEXT,
  "Federal Reporter Citation" TEXT,
  "Westlaw Citation" TEXT,
  "Issue" INTEGER,
  "Weight" REAL,
  "Judge1" TEXT,
  "Judge2" TEXT,
  "Judge3" TEXT,
  "Vote1" INTEGER,
  "Vote2" INTEGER,
  "Vote3" INTEGER,
  "Category" TEXT
)
Powered by Datasette · Query took 158.405ms · Data license: CC Attribution 4.0 License · Data source: fivethirtyeight/data on GitHub