Cases in the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals: tenth-circuit.csv

This table contains the data behind the story For A Trump Nominee, Neil Gorsuch’s Record Is Surprisingly Moderate On Immigration

tenth-circuit.csv contains Tenth Circuit cases decided during Gorsuch’s tenure.

Field Description
Name Name of the case
Date Date of decision
Federal Reporter Citation Case citation, as listed in the Federal Reporter Series
Westlaw Citation Case citation, Westlaw format
Issue Issue number, in cases divided into multiple issues
Weight Weight per issue (total weight per case equals one)
Judge1 Name of first judge
Judge2 Name of second judge
Judge3 Name of third judge
Vote1 Vote of first judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Vote2 Vote of second judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Vote3 Vote of third judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Category Category of case, immigration or discrimination

Note: In immigration cases, partial relief to immigration petitioner is coded as liberal because the petitioner typically seeks just one core remedy (e.g., withholding of removal, adjustment of status, or asylum); in discrimination cases, partial relief is coded as multiple issues because the plaintiff often seeks separate remedies under multiple claims (e.g., disparate treatment, retaliation, etc.) and different sources of law.

Data license: CC Attribution 4.0 License · Data source: fivethirtyeight/data on GitHub

954 rows sorted by Federal Reporter Citation

View and edit SQL

Suggested facets: Issue, Weight, Judge1, Judge2, Vote1, Vote2, Vote3, Category

Link rowid Title Date Federal Reporter Citation ▼ Westlaw Citation Issue Weight Judge1 Judge2 Judge3 Vote1 Vote2 Vote3 Category
3 Glapion v. Jewell 12/14/16 --- Fed.Appx. ---- 2016 WL 7228801 1 1.0 Lucero Holmes Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
4 Dye v. Moniz 12/06/16 --- Fed.Appx. ---- 2016 WL 7093896 1 1.0 Lucero Holmes Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
5 Lister v. City of Wichita, Kansas 11/15/16 --- Fed.Appx. ---- 2016 WL 6694901 1 1.0 Lucero Matheson Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
400 Essary v. Federal Express Corp. 01/06/06 161 Fed.Appx. 782 2006 WL 31128 1 1.0 Lucero Brorby McConnell 0 0 0 Title VII
954 Wei v. Gonzales 01/09/06 161 Fed.Appx. 795 2006 WL 41225 1 1.0 Briscoe McConnell Tymkovich 0 0 0 Immigration
399 Mitchell v. Kraft Pizza Co. 01/10/06 162 Fed.Appx. 801 2006 WL 52787 1 1.0 Kelly McKay McConnell 0 0 0 Title VII
395 Curran v. AMI Fireplace Co. Inc. 01/19/06 163 Fed.Appx. 714 2006 WL 137405 1 1.0 Briscoe McKay Ebel 1 1 1 Title VII
952 Otero v. Gonzales 01/24/06 164 Fed.Appx. 732 2006 WL 165012 1 1.0 Tymkovich Porfilio Baldock 0 0 0 Immigration
951 Infanzon v. Gonzales 01/24/06 164 Fed.Appx. 743 2006 WL 165039 1 1.0 Henry McKay Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
950 Haimour v. Gonzales 01/31/06 165 Fed.Appx. 594 2006 WL 226042 1 1.0 Henry McKay Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
949 Diakhite v. Gonzales 02/02/06 165 Fed.Appx. 636 2006 WL 245579 1 1.0 Briscoe Anderson Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
396 Lombardo v. Potter 01/13/06 166 Fed.Appx. 319 2006 WL 75364 1 1.0 Kelly Porfilio Brorby 0 0 0 Title VII
953 Infanzon v. Comfort 01/18/06 167 Fed.Appx. 11 2006 WL 122450 1 1.0 Briscoe Lucero Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
948 Ariko v. Gonzales 02/07/06 167 Fed.Appx. 27 2006 WL 281111 1 1.0 Tacha Porfilio Johnson 0 0 0 Immigration
394 Douglas v. Norton 01/19/06 167 Fed.Appx. 698 2006 WL 137403 1 1.0 Kelly Anderson O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
947 Basnet v. Gonzales 02/23/06 168 Fed.Appx. 278 2006 WL 417499 1 1.0 Kelly Seymour Murphy 1 1 1 Immigration
946 Nava Mier Y Teran v. Gonzales 02/27/06 168 Fed.Appx. 868 2006 WL 459361 1 1.0 Henry McKay Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
393 Martinez v. U.S. Dept. of Energy 02/06/06 170 Fed.Appx. 517 2006 WL 270230 1 1.0 Lucero Brorby McConnell 0 0 0 Title VII
391 Ransom v. U.S. Postal Service 02/10/06 170 Fed.Appx. 525 2006 WL 308265 1 1.0 Henry McKay Murphy 0 0 0 Title VII
392 Tapia v. City of Albuquerque 02/10/06 170 Fed.Appx. 529 2006 WL 308267 1 1.0 Tymkovich Porfilio Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
944 Al-Ani v. Gonzales 03/20/06 171 Fed.Appx. 715 2006 WL 689443 1 1.0 Henry McKay Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
942 Herrera-Ceja v. Gonzales 03/28/06 172 Fed.Appx. 865 2006 WL 775173 1 1.0 Lucero Ebel Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
941 Sondh v. Gonzales 03/28/06 172 Fed.Appx. 867 2006 WL 775175 1 1.0 Hartz Ebel Tymkovich 0 0 0 Immigration
943 Panjaitan v. Gonzales 03/28/06 172 Fed.Appx. 870 2006 WL 775178 1 1.0 Murphy Seymour McConnell 0 0 0 Immigration
389 Platero v. Williams Field Services Co. 04/05/06 173 Fed.Appx. 705 2006 WL 864851 1 1.0 Lucero Ebel Murphy 0 0 0 Title VII
388 Fye v. Oklahoma Corp. Com'n 04/06/06 175 Fed.Appx. 207 2006 WL 895237 1 1.0 Lucero Ebel Murphy 1 1 1 Title VII
939 Zhen v. Gonzales 04/06/06 175 Fed.Appx. 222 2006 WL 895505 1 1.0 Kelly Baldock Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
934 Rana v. Gonzales 05/18/06 175 Fed.Appx. 988 2006 WL 1389118 1 1.0 Henry McKay Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
387 McIntosh v. Metropolitan Tulsa Transit Authority 04/19/06 176 Fed.Appx. 932 2006 WL 1017649 1 1.0 Tymkovich McKay Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
386 Martinez v. Barnhart 04/25/06 177 Fed.Appx. 796 2006 WL 1076126 1 1.0 Tymkovich Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
937 Gbogbo v. Gonzales 05/02/06 177 Fed.Appx. 831 2006 WL 1149523 1 1.0 Tymkovich McKay Baldock 0 0 0 Immigration
936 Diallo v. Gonzales 05/04/06 178 Fed.Appx. 833 2006 WL 1174624 1 1.0 Lucero Ebel Murphy 1 1 1 Immigration
933 Bagdassaryan v. Gonzales 05/19/06 178 Fed.Appx. 844 2006 WL 1376919 1 1.0 Lucero Ebel Murphy 1 1 1 Immigration
383 Dvorkina v. Jewish Community Center (JCC) 05/03/06 179 Fed.Appx. 454 2006 WL 1165934 1 1.0 Briscoe Anderson Ebel 0 0 0 Title VII
384 Vann v. Southwestern Bell Telephone Co. 05/03/06 179 Fed.Appx. 491 2006 WL 1166120 1 1.0 McConnell Anderson Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
382 Smith v. E.E.O.C. 05/09/06 180 Fed.Appx. 14 2006 WL 1230680 1 1.0 Lucero Baldock Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
381 Lujan v. Johanns 05/25/06 181 Fed.Appx. 735 2006 WL 1431442 1 1.0 Porfilio Baldock Ebel 0 0 0 Title VII
380 Keelan v. Denver Merchandise Mart 05/31/06 182 Fed.Appx. 806 2006 WL 1484906 1 1.0 Lucero Porfilio Hartz 1 1 1 Title VII
379 Osornio v. T-Mobile USA, Inc. 06/02/06 182 Fed.Appx. 834 2006 WL 1520515 1 1.0 Briscoe McKay Brorby 0 0 0 Title VII
375 Sizemore v. State of New Mexico Dept. of Labor 06/22/06 182 Fed.Appx. 848 2006 WL 1704456 1 1.0 Henry Briscoe Murphy 0 0 0 Title VII
932 Peter v. Gonzales 06/13/06 183 Fed.Appx. 805 2006 WL 1617862 1 1.0 Lucero Ebel Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
928 Bastian v. Gonzales 07/06/06 187 Fed.Appx. 891 2006 WL 1851225 1 1.0 McConnell Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Immigration
927 Morales v. Gonzales 07/14/06 188 Fed.Appx. 780 2006 WL 1966658 1 1.0 Kelly Briscoe Lucero 1 1 1 Immigration
926 Ismail v. Bureau of Immigration and Customs Enforcement 07/19/06 189 Fed.Appx. 743 2006 WL 2006018 1 1.0 Hartz Anderson Tymkovich 0 0 0 Immigration
923 Mendiola v. Gonzales 07/27/06 189 Fed.Appx. 810 2006 WL 2076790 1 1.0 Tymkovich Porfilio Baldock 0 0 0 Immigration
374 Brown v. Kempthorne 06/23/06 190 Fed.Appx. 590 2006 WL 1720238 1 1.0 Henry Briscoe O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
373 Romero v. City of Albuquerque 07/12/06 190 Fed.Appx. 597 2006 WL 1901448 1 1.0 Briscoe McKay Brorby 0 0 0 Title VII
371 Carrasco v. Boeing Co. 08/02/06 190 Fed.Appx. 650 2006 WL 2147553 1 1.0 Murphy Ebel McConnell 0 0 0 Title VII
921 Rashid v. Gonzales 08/03/06 190 Fed.Appx. 676 2006 WL 2171522 1 1.0 Kelly Briscoe Lucero 0 0 0 Immigration
922 Diegnan v. Gonzales 08/03/06 190 Fed.Appx. 680 2006 WL 2171525 1 1.0 Tacha O'Brien McConnell 0 0 0 Immigration
918 Daoud v. Gonzales 08/15/06 191 Fed.Appx. 782 2006 WL 2349232 1 1.0 Brorby Ebel Kane 1 1 1 Immigration
916 Leon-Flota v. Gonzales 08/24/06 191 Fed.Appx. 817 2006 WL 2441453 1 1.0 Tacha Hartz Tymkovich 0 0 0 Immigration
919 Yinen Zheng v. Gonzales 08/14/06 192 Fed.Appx. 733 2006 WL 2338085 1 1.0 Brorby Ebel Kane 0 0 0 Immigration
372 Bone v. New Mexico 07/14/06 193 Fed.Appx. 739 2006 WL 1966651 1 1.0 Tymkovich Barrett Anderson 0 0 0 Title VII
914 Garcia-Ortiz v. Gonzales 09/06/06 194 Fed.Appx. 513 2006 WL 2556364 1 1.0 Henry Briscoe Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
910 Umboh v. Gonzales 10/05/06 195 Fed.Appx. 798 2006 WL 2832076 1 1.0 Hartz Holloway Baldock 0 0 0 Immigration
913 Thorn v. Gonzales 09/13/06 196 Fed.Appx. 663 2006 WL 2615532 1 1.0 Tacha O'Brien McConnell 0 0 0 Immigration
911 Mondal v. Gonzales 10/04/06 198 Fed.Appx. 718 2006 WL 2821373 1 1.0 Henry Anderson McConnell 0 0 0 Immigration
362 Edwards v. Potter 10/04/06 198 Fed.Appx. 736 2006 WL 2821383 1 1.0 Henry Briscoe O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
363 Johnson v. City of Tulsa 09/22/06 199 Fed.Appx. 677 2006 WL 2709647 1 1.0 Hartz Anderson Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
364 Ostler v. Anderson 09/18/06 200 Fed.Appx. 750 2006 WL 2666062 1 1.0 Brorby Ebel Kane 0 0 0 Title VII
908 Tobar v. Gonzales 10/11/06 200 Fed.Appx. 796 2006 WL 2879067 1 1.0 O'Brien Porfilio Anderson 0 0 0 Immigration
360 Sandle v. Principi 10/17/06 201 Fed.Appx. 579 2006 WL 2949133 1 1.0 O'Brien Holloway Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
907 Boutou v. Gonzales 10/20/06 201 Fed.Appx. 630 2006 WL 2988708 1 1.0 Henry Anderson McConnell 0 0 0 Immigration
906 Mulianto v. Gonzales 10/23/06 201 Fed.Appx. 637 2006 WL 3001176 1 1.0 Tymkovich Baldock Figa 0 0 0 Immigration
905 Essuman v. Gonzales 11/01/06 203 Fed.Appx. 204 2006 WL 3086709 1 1.0 Henry Anderson McConnell 0 0 0 Immigration
924 Tillett v. Booker 07/25/06 204 Fed.Appx. 732 2006 WL 2053870 1 1.0 Murphy Ebel O'Brien 0 0 0 Immigration
901 Onogwu v. Gonzales 12/13/06 204 Fed.Appx. 775 2006 WL 3616709 1 1.0 O'Brien Brorby Brown 0 0 0 Immigration
912 Asagwara v. Gonzales 09/18/06 205 Fed.Appx. 644 2006 WL 2666054 1 1.0 O'Brien Porfilio Anderson 0 0 0 Immigration
904 Saeed v. Gonzales 11/09/06 205 Fed.Appx. 671 2006 WL 3237582 1 1.0 Tymkovich Baldock Figa 0 0 0 Immigration
358 Richardson v. Safeway, Inc. 11/17/06 206 Fed.Appx. 754 2006 WL 3334508 1 1.0 Murphy Seymour McConnell 0 0 0 Title VII
903 Ebrahim v. Gonzales 11/28/06 206 Fed.Appx. 796 2006 WL 3411524 1 1.0 Tacha Hartz Tymkovich 0 0 0 Immigration
902 Moreno v. Gonzales 12/01/06 206 Fed.Appx. 815 2006 WL 3462177 1 1.0 O'Brien Brorby Brown 0 0 0 Immigration
900 Ahlan v. Gonzales 12/19/06 209 Fed.Appx. 791 2006 WL 3720305 1 1.0 Tymkovich Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Immigration
357 Vigil v. City of Albuquerque 11/28/06 210 Fed.Appx. 758 2006 WL 3411446 1 1.0 Murphy Brorby Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
356 Madrid v. Phelps Dodge Corp. 11/29/06 211 Fed.Appx. 676 2006 WL 3423474 1 1.0 O'Brien Brorby Brown 0 0 0 Title VII
355 Howard v. County of Las Animas in Colorado 12/07/06 212 Fed.Appx. 711 2006 WL 3518000 1 1.0 Tymkovich Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
352 Paloni v. City of Albuquerque Police Dept. 12/27/06 212 Fed.Appx. 716 2006 WL 3791286 1 1.0 Murphy Brorby Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
349 Jenkins v. Educational Credit Management Corp. 01/04/07 212 Fed.Appx. 729 2007 WL 18919 1 0.5 Kelly Lucero Hartz 1 1 1 Title VII
350 Jenkins v. Educational Credit Management Corp. 01/04/07 212 Fed.Appx. 729 2007 WL 18919 2 0.5 Kelly Lucero Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
899 Kalule v. Gonzales 01/12/07 213 Fed.Appx. 657 2007 WL 80700 1 1.0 Porfilio Baldock Ebel 0 0 0 Immigration
347 Cooper v. American Airlines, Inc. 01/23/07 213 Fed.Appx. 714 2007 WL 155841 1 1.0 Holmes McKay Brorby 0 0 0 Title VII
897 Mucuuthi v. Gonzales 01/23/07 213 Fed.Appx. 717 2007 WL 156024 1 1.0 Kelly Lucero Hartz 0 0 0 Immigration
346 Hardman v. AutoZone, Inc. 01/25/07 214 Fed.Appx. 758 2007 WL 182535 1 1.0 Tymkovich Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
895 Serva-Lozano v. Gonzales 01/29/07 215 Fed.Appx. 704 2007 WL 211282 1 1.0 Kelly McKay Lucero 0 0 0 Immigration
893 Leonard v. Gonzales 02/14/07 216 Fed.Appx. 781 2007 WL 466279 1 1.0 Holmes McKay Brorby 0 0 0 Immigration
890 Luntungan v. Gonzales 02/16/07 216 Fed.Appx. 815 2007 WL 495295 1 1.0 Hartz Holloway Baldock 0 0 0 Immigration
896 Abiodun v. Gonzales 01/26/07 217 Fed.Appx. 738 2007 WL 196572 1 1.0 Holmes McKay Brorby 0 0 0 Immigration
892 Meza-Hernandez v. Gonzales 02/14/07 217 Fed.Appx. 746 2007 WL 466281 1 1.0 Holmes McKay Brorby 0 0 0 Immigration
894 Mart v. Gonzales 02/14/07 217 Fed.Appx. 751 2007 WL 466315 1 1.0 Porfilio Baldock Ebel 0 0 0 Immigration
883 Rivas v. Gonzales 04/04/07 220 Fed.Appx. 892 2007 WL 987431 1 1.0 Briscoe Mcwilliams Tymkovich 0 0 0 Immigration
888 Schultz v. Gonzales 03/21/07 221 Fed.Appx. 726 2007 WL 841646 1 1.0 Porfilio Baldock Ebel 0 0 0 Immigration
891 Niania v. Gonzales 02/15/07 222 Fed.Appx. 684 2007 WL 475880 1 1.0 O'Brien Brorby Brown 0 0 0 Immigration
889 Ba v. Gonzales 03/16/07 222 Fed.Appx. 702 2007 WL 779239 1 1.0 Briscoe Mcwilliams Tymkovich 1 1 1 Immigration
340 McNulty v. Sandoval County 03/27/07 222 Fed.Appx. 770 2007 WL 901925 1 1.0 Holmes McKay Brorby 0 0 0 Title VII
887 Flores-Buenrostro v. Gonzales 03/27/07 222 Fed.Appx. 782 2007 WL 901960 1 1.0 Henry Tymkovich Holmes 0 0 0 Immigration
337 Kenney v. Millennium Rail, Inc. 03/28/07 224 Fed.Appx. 792 2007 WL 915086 1 1.0 Henry Briscoe O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
870 Hafeez v. Gonzales 05/22/07 224 Fed.Appx. 849 2007 WL 1475281 1 1.0 Henry Baldock Murphy 0 0 0 Immigration
871 Panjaitan v. Gonzales 05/22/07 224 Fed.Appx. 853 2007 WL 1475282 1 1.0 Lucero Brorby McConnell 0 0 0 Immigration
354 Kenney v. NKC of America 12/12/06 225 Fed.Appx. 727 2006 WL 3598432 1 1.0 Tacha Hartz Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII

Next page

Advanced export

JSON shape: default, array, newline-delimited

CSV options:

CREATE TABLE "tenth-circuit/tenth-circuit" (
"Title" TEXT,
  "Date" TEXT,
  "Federal Reporter Citation" TEXT,
  "Westlaw Citation" TEXT,
  "Issue" INTEGER,
  "Weight" REAL,
  "Judge1" TEXT,
  "Judge2" TEXT,
  "Judge3" TEXT,
  "Vote1" INTEGER,
  "Vote2" INTEGER,
  "Vote3" INTEGER,
  "Category" TEXT
)
Powered by Datasette · Query took 138.929ms · Data license: CC Attribution 4.0 License · Data source: fivethirtyeight/data on GitHub