home / fivethirtyeight

Cases in the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals: tenth-circuit.csv

This table contains the data behind the story For A Trump Nominee, Neil Gorsuch’s Record Is Surprisingly Moderate On Immigration

tenth-circuit.csv contains Tenth Circuit cases decided during Gorsuch’s tenure.

Field Description
Name Name of the case
Date Date of decision
Federal Reporter Citation Case citation, as listed in the Federal Reporter Series
Westlaw Citation Case citation, Westlaw format
Issue Issue number, in cases divided into multiple issues
Weight Weight per issue (total weight per case equals one)
Judge1 Name of first judge
Judge2 Name of second judge
Judge3 Name of third judge
Vote1 Vote of first judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Vote2 Vote of second judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Vote3 Vote of third judge. 1 = liberal, 0 = conservative.
Category Category of case, immigration or discrimination

Note: In immigration cases, partial relief to immigration petitioner is coded as liberal because the petitioner typically seeks just one core remedy (e.g., withholding of removal, adjustment of status, or asylum); in discrimination cases, partial relief is coded as multiple issues because the plaintiff often seeks separate remedies under multiple claims (e.g., disparate treatment, retaliation, etc.) and different sources of law.

Data license: CC Attribution 4.0 License · Data source: fivethirtyeight/data on GitHub

954 rows

View and edit SQL

Suggested facets: Issue, Weight, Judge1, Judge2, Vote1, Vote2, Vote3, Category

Link rowid Title Date Federal Reporter Citation Westlaw Citation Issue Weight Judge1 Judge2 Judge3 Vote1 Vote2 Vote3 Category
1 Hansen v. SkyWest Airlines 12/21/16 844 F.3d 914 2016 WL 7387139 1 0.5 Briscoe McKay Matheson 1 1 1 Title VII
2 Hansen v. SkyWest Airlines 12/21/16 844 F.3d 914 2016 WL 7387139 2 0.5 Briscoe McKay Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
3 Glapion v. Jewell 12/14/16 --- Fed.Appx. ---- 2016 WL 7228801 1 1.0 Lucero Holmes Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
4 Dye v. Moniz 12/06/16 --- Fed.Appx. ---- 2016 WL 7093896 1 1.0 Lucero Holmes Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
5 Lister v. City of Wichita, Kansas 11/15/16 --- Fed.Appx. ---- 2016 WL 6694901 1 1.0 Lucero Matheson Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
6 ElHelbawy v. Pritzker 10/13/16 663 Fed.Appx. 658 2016 WL 5947456 1 1.0 Tymkovich Bacharach Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
7 Chung v. El Paso School District #11 08/11/16 659 Fed.Appx. 953 2016 WL 4258835 1 1.0 Hartz Holmes McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
8 Bird v. West Valley City 08/08/16 832 F.3d 1188 129 Fair Empl.Prac.Cas. (BNA) 685 1 1.0 Matheson Baldock Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
9 Drury v. BNSF Railway Company 08/02/16 657 Fed.Appx. 785 2016 WL 4119068 1 1.0 Tymkovich Lucero Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
10 Callahan v. Communication Graphics, Inc. 07/21/16 657 Fed.Appx. 739 2016 WL 3983511 1 1.0 Gorsuch Baldock McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
11 Williams v. McKee 07/20/16 655 Fed.Appx. 677 2016 WL 3995755 1 1.0 Tymkovich Murphy Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
12 Ghogomu v. Delta Airlines Global Services, LLC 06/16/16 652 Fed.Appx. 701 2016 WL 3409754 1 1.0 Briscoe Bacharach McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
13 Glapion v. Castro 05/12/16 646 Fed.Appx. 668 2016 WL 2755473 1 1.0 Kelly O'Brien Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
14 Johnson v. Oklahoma Department of Transp. 04/20/16 645 Fed.Appx. 765 2016 WL 1583596 1 1.0 Gorsuch McKay Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
15 Walton v. Powell 04/19/16 821 F.3d 1204 2016 WL 1566692 1 1.0 Gorsuch Murphy Moritz 1 1 1 Title VII
16 Aman v. Dillon Companies, Inc. 04/15/16 645 Fed.Appx. 719 2016 WL 1533999 1 1.0 Briscoe Lucero McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
17 McGowan v. Board of Trustees of Metropolitan State University of Denver 04/13/16 645 Fed.Appx. 667 2016 WL 1445420 1 1.0 Briscoe Lucero McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
18 Robinson v. St. John Medical Center, Inc. 04/13/16 645 Fed.Appx. 644 2016 WL 1444740 1 1.0 Gorsuch Matheson Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
19 Tuffa v. Flight Services & Systems, Inc. 04/05/16 644 Fed.Appx. 853 2016 WL 1319366 1 1.0 Gorsuch McKay Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
20 Unal v. Los Alamos Public Schools 01/29/16 638 Fed.Appx. 729 2016 WL 360758 1 0.5 Briscoe Lucero McHugh 1 1 1 Title VII
21 Unal v. Los Alamos Public Schools 01/29/16 638 Fed.Appx. 729 2016 WL 360758 2 0.5 Briscoe Lucero McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
22 Hannah v. Cowlishaw 01/29/16 628 Fed.Appx. 629 2016 WL 362981 1 1.0 Lucero Gorsuch McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
23 Montoya v. Hunter Douglas Window Fashions, Inc. 01/25/16 636 Fed.Appx. 744 2016 WL 285057 1 1.0 Phillips McHugh Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
24 Mancell v. McHugh 01/25/16 639 Fed.Appx. 527 2016 WL 285087 1 1.0 Hartz Baldock Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
25 L'Ggrke v. Asset Plus Corp. 01/20/16 641 Fed.Appx. 779 2016 WL 231150 1 1.0 Hartz Baldock Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
26 Lewis v. Twenty-First Century Bean Processing 01/06/16 638 Fed.Appx. 701 2016 WL 66334 1 1.0 Gorsuch McKay Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
27 Amos v. City of Claremore 12/23/15 635 Fed.Appx. 517 2015 WL 9311375 1 1.0 Kelly Bacharach Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
28 Lounds v. Lincare, Inc. 12/22/15 812 F.3d 1208 2015 WL 9299074 1 0.5 Kelly Holmes McHugh 1 1 1 Title VII
29 Lounds v. Lincare, Inc. 12/22/15 812 F.3d 1208 2015 WL 9299074 2 0.5 Kelly Holmes McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
30 Sanders v. Anoatubby 11/23/15 631 Fed.Appx. 618 2015 WL 7423038 1 1.0 Gorsuch O'Brien Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
31 McElroy v. American Family Ins. 10/30/15 630 Fed.Appx. 847 2015 WL 6576261 1 1.0 Briscoe Holmes Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
32 Hung Thai Pham v. James 10/20/15 630 Fed.Appx. 735 2015 WL 6144067 1 1.0 Tymkovich Holmes McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
33 Brown v. Lowe's Home Centers 10/08/15 627 Fed.Appx. 720 2015 WL 5847586 1 1.0 Holmes Matheson Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
34 Thomas v. Berry Plastics Corp. 09/25/15 803 F.3d 510 2015 WL 5638027 1 1.0 Tymkovich Ebel Gorsuch 0 0 0 Title VII
35 Arabalo v. City of Denver 09/09/15 625 Fed.Appx. 851 2015 WL 5235740 1 1.0 Kelly Phillips Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
36 Zisumbo v. Ogden Regional Medical Center 09/04/15 801 F.3d 1185 2015 WL 5172860 1 0.5 Kelly Phillips Moritz 1 1 1 Title VII
37 Zisumbo v. Ogden Regional Medical Center 09/04/15 801 F.3d 1185 2015 WL 5172860 2 0.5 Kelly Phillips Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
38 Macias v. Southwest Cheese Co., LLC 08/24/15 624 Fed.Appx. 628 2015 WL 4998338 1 0.5 Holmes Matheson Bacharach 1 1 1 Title VII
39 Macias v. Southwest Cheese Co., LLC 08/24/15 624 Fed.Appx. 628 2015 WL 4998338 2 0.5 Holmes Matheson Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
40 Martin v. Mt. St. Mary's University Online 08/11/15 620 Fed.Appx. 661 2015 WL 4734707 1 1.0 Holmes Matheson Phillips 0 0 0 Title VII
41 Didier v. Abbott Laboratories 07/31/15 614 Fed.Appx. 366 2015 WL 4591931 1 1.0 Hartz Holmes Phillips 0 0 0 Title VII
42 Bandi v. Colvin 07/16/15 618 Fed.Appx. 426 2015 WL 4296716 1 1.0 Matheson Bacharach Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
43 Llamas v. QC Financial Services, Inc. 07/13/15 621 Fed.Appx. 906 2015 WL 4175020 1 1.0 Kelly Holmes McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
44 Jordan v. Dillon Companies 07/09/15 618 Fed.Appx. 926 2015 WL 4126952 1 1.0 Hartz Phillips McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
45 Taite v. Ramos 07/08/15 618 Fed.Appx. 392 2015 WL 4098136 1 0.5 Hartz Phillips McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
46 Taite v. Ramos 07/08/15 618 Fed.Appx. 392 2015 WL 4098136 2 0.5 Hartz Phillips McHugh 1 1 1 Title VII
47 Smith v. Global Staffing 06/17/15 621 Fed.Appx. 899 2015 WL 3757125 1 1.0 Gorsuch O'Brien Phillips 0 0 0 Title VII
48 Gad v. Kansas State University 05/27/15 787 F.3d 1032 2015 WL 3389211 1 1.0 Tymkovich Gorsuch Bacharach 1 1 1 Title VII
49 Hare v. Donahoe 05/04/15 608 Fed.Appx. 627 2015 WL 1963777 1 1.0 Briscoe Lucero Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
50 Montano v. Public Service Co. of New Mexico 04/23/15 610 Fed.Appx. 748 2015 WL 1840938 1 1.0 Bacharach Porfilio Baldock 1 1 1 Title VII
51 Chavez-Acosta v. Southwest Cheese Co., LLC 04/20/15 610 Fed.Appx. 722 2015 WL 1768989 1 1.0 Kelly Baldock Phillips 0 0 0 Title VII
52 Chytka v. Wright Tree Service, Inc. 03/25/15 617 Fed.Appx. 841 2015 WL 1320241 1 1.0 Moritz Porfilio Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
53 McDonald v. Boeing Co. 03/03/15 602 Fed.Appx. 452 2015 WL 876791 1 1.0 Kelly Baldock Phillips 0 0 0 Title VII
54 McCauley v. Board of Com'rs for Bernalillo County 03/02/15 603 Fed.Appx. 730 2015 WL 858091 1 1.0 Kelly Baldock Moritz 0 0 0 Title VII
55 Avington v. Metropolitan Tulsa Urban League 02/11/15 603 Fed.Appx. 662 2015 Fair Empl.Prac.Cas. (BNA) 176,405 1 1.0 Gorsuch O'Brien Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
56 Bejar v. McDonald 02/03/15 601 Fed.Appx. 628 2015 WL 428120 1 1.0 Hartz McKay McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
57 Riser v. QEP Energy 01/27/15 776 F.3d 1191 2015 WL 328597 1 0.5 Kelly Lucero Hartz 1 1 1 Title VII
58 Riser v. QEP Energy 01/27/15 776 F.3d 1191 2015 WL 328597 2 0.5 Kelly Lucero Hartz 0 0 0 Title VII
59 Davis v. James 01/15/15 597 Fed.Appx. 983 2015 WL 178982 1 1.0 Kelly Anderson Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
60 Brainard v. City of Topeka 01/13/15 597 Fed.Appx. 974 2015 WL 150288 1 1.0 Kelly Anderson Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
61 Estate of Bassatt v. School Dist. No. 1 in the City and County of Denver 12/31/14 775 F.3d 1233 2014 WL 7399052 1 1.0 Kelly Bacharach Phillips 0 0 0 Title VII
62 Myers v. Knight Protective Service, Inc. 12/22/14 774 F.3d 1246 2014 WL 7240089 1 1.0 Gorsuch O'Brien Phillips 0 0 0 Title VII
63 Hartigan v. Utah Transit Authority 12/10/14 595 Fed.Appx. 779 2014 WL 6934370 1 1.0 Hartz McKay McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
64 Al-Kazaz v. Unitherm Food Systems, Inc. 12/08/14 594 Fed.Appx. 460 2014 WL 6888504 1 1.0 Holmes Bacharach McHugh 0 0 0 Title VII
65 Melin v. Verizon Business, Inc. 11/25/14 595 Fed.Appx. 736 2014 WL 6679430 1 1.0 Kelly Anderson Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
66 Ward v. Jewell 11/24/14 772 F.3d 1199 125 Fair Empl.Prac.Cas. (BNA) 437 1 1.0 Kelly Bacharach Phillips 0 0 0 Title VII
67 Stewart v. Oklahoma ex rel. Oklahoma Office of Juvenile Affairs 09/25/14 587 Fed.Appx. 455 2014 WL 4746296 1 1.0 Kelly Porfilio Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
68 Benton v. Town of South Fork 09/24/14 587 Fed.Appx. 447 2014 WL 4723710 1 1.0 Kelly Anderson Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
69 Smith v. United Parcel Service 09/05/14 578 Fed.Appx. 755 2014 WL 4377680 1 1.0 Briscoe Porfilio O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
70 Tabor v. Hilti, Inc. 09/02/14 577 Fed.Appx. 870 2014 WL 4290581 1 1.0 Hartz Tymkovich Holmes 0 0 0 Title VII
71 Green v. Donahoe 07/28/14 760 F.3d 1135 2014 WL 3703823 1 0.5 Hartz McKay Matheson 1 1 1 Title VII
72 Green v. Donahoe 07/28/14 760 F.3d 1135 2014 WL 3703823 2 0.5 Hartz McKay Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
73 Clark v. Cache Valley Elec. Co. 07/25/14 573 Fed.Appx. 693 2014 WL 3685996 1 1.0 Briscoe Porfilio O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
74 Juarez-Galvan v. United Parcel Service, Inc. 07/22/14 572 Fed.Appx. 619 2014 WL 3585735 1 1.0 Lucero Murphy Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
75 Knitter v. Corvias Military Living, LLC 07/15/14 758 F.3d 1214 2014 WL 3409962 1 1.0 Gorsuch Matheson Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
76 Barrett v. Salt Lake County 06/13/14 754 F.3d 864 2014 WL 2619799 1 1.0 Lucero O'Brien Gorsuch 1 1 1 Title VII
77 Townsend-Johnson v. Rio Rancho Public Schools 06/11/14 568 Fed.Appx. 542 2014 WL 2598702 1 1.0 Gorsuch Baldock Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
78 Davis v. Unified School Dist. 500 05/05/14 750 F.3d 1168 305 Ed. Law Rep. 23 1 1.0 Briscoe Porfilio O'Brien 0 0 0 Title VII
79 Ridgell-Boltz v. Colvin 04/30/14 565 Fed.Appx. 680 2014 WL 1688349 1 0.5 Gorsuch McKay Anderson 1 1 1 Title VII
80 Ridgell-Boltz v. Colvin 04/30/14 565 Fed.Appx. 680 2014 WL 1688349 2 0.5 Gorsuch McKay Anderson 0 0 0 Title VII
81 Hanson v. Colorado Judicial Dept. 04/29/14 564 Fed.Appx. 916 2014 WL 1677874 1 1.0 Lucero Seymour Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII
82 Dyer v. Lane 04/25/14 564 Fed.Appx. 391 2014 WL 1647057 1 1.0 Holmes Anderson Baldock 0 0 0 Title VII
83 Potter v. Synerlink Corp. 04/21/14 562 Fed.Appx. 665 2014 WL 1562163 1 0.5 Lucero O'Brien Matheson 0 0 0 Title VII
84 Potter v. Synerlink Corp. 04/21/14 562 Fed.Appx. 665 2014 WL 1562163 2 0.5 Lucero O'Brien Matheson 1 0 1 Title VII
85 Ning Lu v. Kendall 04/14/14 561 Fed.Appx. 751 2014 WL 1408894 1 1.0 Lucero Tymkovich Phillips 0 0 0 Title VII
86 Asebedo v. Kansas State University 03/17/14 559 Fed.Appx. 668 2014 WL 998417 1 0.5 Phillips McKay Anderson 1 1 1 Title VII
87 Asebedo v. Kansas State University 03/17/14 559 Fed.Appx. 668 2014 WL 998417 2 0.5 Phillips McKay Anderson 1 1 1 Title VII
88 Eisenhour v. Weber County 03/12/14 744 F.3d 1220 2014 WL 958468 1 0.5 Gorsuch Baldock Bacharach 1 1 1 Title VII
89 Eisenhour v. Weber County 03/12/14 744 F.3d 1220 2014 WL 958468 2 0.5 Gorsuch Baldock Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
90 Kramer v. Wasatch County Sheriff's Office 02/25/14 743 F.3d 726 121 Fair Empl.Prac.Cas. (BNA) 1329 1 0.5 Briscoe Seymour Bacharach 1 1 1 Title VII
91 Kramer v. Wasatch County Sheriff's Office 02/25/14 743 F.3d 726 121 Fair Empl.Prac.Cas. (BNA) 1329 2 0.5 Briscoe Seymour Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
92 Kenfield v. Colorado Dept. of Public Health & Environment 02/14/14 557 Fed.Appx. 728 2014 WL 563588 1 1.0 Briscoe Seymour Lucero 0 0 0 Title VII
93 Richardson v. Gallagher 01/29/14 553 Fed.Appx. 816 122 Fair Empl.Prac.Cas. (BNA) 12 1 1.0 Tymkovich Brorby Murphy 0 0 0 Title VII
94 White v. Oklahoma 01/28/14 552 Fed.Appx. 840 2014 WL 292448 1 1.0 Tymkovich Anderson Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
95 Zamora v. Board of Educ. for Las Cruces Public Schools 01/24/14 553 Fed.Appx. 786 2014 WL 260293 1 1.0 Lucero Baldock Brorby 0 0 0 Title VII
96 Hester v. Jewell 01/21/14 553 Fed.Appx. 783 2014 WL 211868 1 1.0 Lucero McKay Murphy 0 0 0 Title VII
97 Benton v. Town of South Fork and Police Dept. 01/09/14 553 Fed.Appx. 772 2014 WL 67867 1 1.0 Lucero Brorby Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
98 Buhendwa v. Regional Transp. Dist. 01/07/14 553 Fed.Appx. 768 2014 WL 44001 1 1.0 Lucero Brorby Bacharach 0 0 0 Title VII
99 Zoutomou v. Copper 12/23/13 550 Fed.Appx. 647 2013 WL 6727524 1 1.0 Kelly Tymkovich Phillips 0 0 0 Title VII
100 Debord v. Mercy Health System of Kansas, Inc. 11/26/13 737 F.3d 642 2013 WL 6170983 1 1.0 Kelly Murphy Tymkovich 0 0 0 Title VII

Next page

Advanced export

JSON shape: default, array

CSV options:

CREATE TABLE "tenth-circuit/tenth-circuit" (
"Title" TEXT,
  "Date" TEXT,
  "Federal Reporter Citation" TEXT,
  "Westlaw Citation" TEXT,
  "Issue" INTEGER,
  "Weight" REAL,
  "Judge1" TEXT,
  "Judge2" TEXT,
  "Judge3" TEXT,
  "Vote1" INTEGER,
  "Vote2" INTEGER,
  "Vote3" INTEGER,
  "Category" TEXT
)
Powered by Datasette · Query took 36.838ms · Data license: CC Attribution 4.0 License · Data source: fivethirtyeight/data on GitHub